Listen Full Story:
Read Full Story:
Edgar Freemantle was a successful construction magnate in Minnesota, a man with a solid life, a loving wife, and two grown daughters. Everything changed the day a crane accident crushed his truck and nearly killed him. He lost his right arm and suffered a severe head injury that left him struggling with memory, speech, and violent fits of anger. His wife, Pam, could not cope with his unpredictable rages, and soon after, she left him. In despair, and with his life collapsing, Edgar turned to Dr. Kamen, a neuropsychologist who suggested a change of scenery might help him recover. He advised Edgar to do something creative, something that could reconnect the damaged parts of his mind. So, Edgar left Minnesota behind and rented a house on Duma Key, a narrow stretch of land off the coast of Florida, washed by the Gulf of Mexico and filled with strange, whispering light.
The house was called Big Pink—a sprawling, coral-colored mansion overlooking the sea. It was beautiful, but it seemed to hum with a presence of its own. Edgar felt drawn to it immediately, as if the place had been waiting for him. He began to draw and then paint, using his left hand. What started as a distraction soon became an obsession. He painted the sunsets, the sea, and the island’s strange beauty. But his paintings were not ordinary. They had a kind of power—an energy that seemed to come from somewhere beyond himself. When he painted something, it sometimes changed reality. One painting could heal an injured girl. Another could reveal hidden truths. Edgar didn’t understand how it was happening, but he felt as if the island was giving him this gift—or perhaps, using him.
Edgar met his neighbor, Wireman, a former lawyer who now worked as caretaker for an elderly woman named Elizabeth Eastlake. Elizabeth had once been a brilliant artist herself and came from a wealthy family that owned much of Duma Key. But now she was old and slipping into dementia. She often warned Edgar to be careful with his art, saying strange things like “Beware the girl in the water” and “It’s all connected through the shells.” Her mind wandered, but her fear was genuine. Wireman, kind and charismatic, became Edgar’s closest friend. He was grieving his own tragedy—the suicide of his wife and daughter—and found comfort in caring for Elizabeth and in Edgar’s company. The three of them formed an unlikely bond, united by loss and by the strange pull of Duma Key.
As Edgar’s art grew in intensity, so did the strange phenomena surrounding it. He painted portraits that seemed alive, seascapes that shimmered with unseen movement, and faces that appeared on the canvas before he even touched the brush. He began having visions—of the sea rising, of a shipwreck, of something ancient and female stirring beneath the waves. Elizabeth recognized it. She called it Perse, a dark force that had haunted Duma Key for generations. When she was a child, she too had painted under Perse’s influence. Her family had tried to suppress it, but the power never died—it only waited for another artist to channel it. Now, it had found Edgar.
Wireman began to notice that Edgar’s paintings affected people who saw them. Some felt peace; others felt haunted. One painting that Edgar made for his daughter Ilse seemed to bring her good fortune, but it also bound her to the same dark current. Edgar realized his talent was not entirely his own—it was Perse’s, working through him, feeding on his creativity, his pain, and his love. The more he painted, the stronger she became. Elizabeth’s condition worsened, and in her clearer moments, she told them the truth. As a girl, she and her sisters had discovered Perse through shells and paintings after a shipwreck off the coast brought the entity to shore. Perse was a kind of sea goddess or demon, trapped beneath the island but able to influence artists and dreamers. Through art, she could touch the world again.
The more Edgar learned, the more dangerous things became. Elizabeth’s memories fractured, but in one lucid moment, she destroyed many of her old paintings to weaken Perse’s hold. It was already too late. Perse began manifesting again—through whispers, through paintings that would not dry, and through nightmares that felt more real than waking life. Wireman and Edgar tried to keep Elizabeth safe, but the old woman eventually succumbed to Perse’s pull, vanishing into the sea in a moment both beautiful and terrifying. Edgar, grief-stricken, knew that if he didn’t stop Perse, she would spread her influence far beyond Duma Key.
Driven by purpose, Edgar began painting not for creation but for destruction. Each brushstroke became a weapon. He discovered that he could trap Perse’s essence within his art, but doing so came at a cost. His own body and mind grew weaker. The sea, once a place of beauty and healing, turned ominous, its voice calling him by name. He and Wireman dug into the island’s history and found that Duma Key had been built upon the ruins of the Eastlake family’s secrets—layer upon layer of tragedy tied to the same dark power. Shipwrecks, drownings, disappearances—all led back to Perse.
Edgar’s connection to Perse deepened until he understood that she was feeding on pain and creativity alike. The more he painted his grief, the more she awakened. He resolved to stop painting entirely, but the visions would not let him rest. When Ilse came to visit, he realized Perse’s influence had reached her. The entity had taken hold of Edgar’s art, using it to cross the boundary between the island and the outside world. A storm came to Duma Key, and with it, the final confrontation.
During the tempest, Edgar and Wireman returned to Big Pink. The house seemed alive, pulsating with light and whispers. Perse’s voice echoed from the ocean, promising Edgar peace if he surrendered. Instead, he painted a final work—a masterpiece that would seal her away. He depicted the dark goddess bound beneath the waves, surrounded by light that could never be broken. As the painting neared completion, the storm ripped through the island. The sea rose as if in fury, and the entire house seemed to dissolve into salt and wind. Wireman helped Edgar escape, but the act drained him completely. Perse’s voice faded into silence, trapped again in the deep.
After the storm, Duma Key changed. The island was quiet, its magic gone or perhaps merely sleeping. Edgar recovered enough to leave, but the cost was unbearable. Wireman, weakened by his injuries and by years of psychic connection to Elizabeth, passed away soon after. Ilse’s life too was touched by tragedy—she died under mysterious circumstances, possibly a final reach of Perse’s curse. Edgar buried her and, in his grief, returned to Duma Key one last time. There, he painted his final picture—not for power, not for glory, but to let go. He painted Wireman, Elizabeth, and Ilse together in a place of light, safe and far from the sea.
Then he destroyed it.
As the canvas burned, Edgar felt something shift inside him—a release. The wind carried the ashes toward the Gulf, and the sea was calm again. Duma Key seemed empty, its strange shimmer gone. Edgar knew Perse was still down there, somewhere in the deep, waiting for another dreamer, another artist, another wound to enter through. But for now, she was silent. He left the island behind, carrying the weight of his loss and the knowledge that creativity, like the sea, could heal—or destroy.
And sometimes, it did both.