Listen Full Story:
Read Full Story:
In the quiet Benedictine Abbey of Shrewsbury, the monks lived peacefully under the guidance of their Abbot. Among them was Brother Cadfael, a kind and wise man who once lived as a soldier and sailor before finding peace in the monastery. He cared for the monastery’s herb garden and was known for his sharp mind and gentle heart. One day, the ambitious Prior Robert decided that the Abbey needed a holy relic to bring fame and pilgrims. He heard of Saint Winifred, a Welsh saint buried in a remote village called Gwytherin, and declared that her bones should be brought to Shrewsbury.
The monks were divided about the idea, but Cadfael was chosen to accompany the group because he spoke Welsh and knew the land well. Alongside him were several monks, including Brother Columbanus, a pious but frail man; Brother Jerome, who admired Robert too much; and Brother John, who simply followed orders. They set off on their journey through the hills of Wales, carrying with them a sense of purpose but also quiet unease. The villagers of Gwytherin, when they arrived, were not pleased to see strangers claiming the bones of their beloved saint.
In Gwytherin lived a simple and devout community. The local priest, Father Huw, greeted the monks politely but made it clear that the people would not easily give up Saint Winifred’s remains. She had protected their village for centuries, and her spirit was part of their daily lives. Among the villagers was Rhisiart, a respected landowner and a man of strong faith. He spoke firmly against the monks, saying the saint belonged to Wales, not England. Prior Robert, proud and determined, was angered by this resistance and refused to listen.
Rhisiart’s daughter, Sioned, was a spirited and intelligent young woman who cared deeply for her father. She was in love with Engelard, a man who had once been a soldier and now worked for Rhisiart. Some villagers distrusted Engelard because he was not Welsh by birth, but Sioned saw his honesty and courage. When Rhisiart opposed the monks, it was not just pride but love for his people and respect for their traditions that drove him. Cadfael, unlike his fellow monks, admired Rhisiart’s strength and began to sense that the mission was not truly for God’s glory but for the Abbey’s ambition.
That evening, tension filled the air. Prior Robert and his followers plotted ways to persuade the villagers, but Cadfael warned them that faith cannot be taken by force. The next morning, the village was shaken by shocking news: Rhisiart was found dead in the woods, an arrow through his chest. The peaceful mission turned into a grim mystery. Everyone was alarmed, and suspicion spread quickly. Engelard, being an outsider, was the first to be blamed. The villagers whispered that he had quarreled with Rhisiart, but Sioned swore that her beloved was innocent.
Cadfael examined the body and the scene carefully. His experience from his old life told him that this was no accident. The arrow had been shot from close range, and the wound seemed deliberate. Yet, something felt wrong. The quarrel that killed Rhisiart belonged to a type of crossbow the monks had carried for protection on their journey. Cadfael realized the truth was closer than anyone wanted to admit. He quietly began his own investigation, determined to uncover the killer before an innocent man was punished.
Sioned begged Cadfael to help prove Engelard’s innocence. She trusted the wise monk, and he promised to find the truth. Cadfael questioned the monks and the villagers, listening to every detail with care. Brother Columbanus, who had been frail and quiet, now appeared strangely radiant and full of energy. He claimed to have seen Saint Winifred in a vision, telling him that her bones should be taken to Shrewsbury. Prior Robert saw this as divine approval and announced that the saint herself had given permission.
Cadfael, however, remained suspicious. He knew true miracles were rare and that ambition often dressed itself as faith. When he visited the woods again, he noticed faint footprints near the scene—monk’s sandals. He remembered Columbanus had been walking near that area the day before. Slowly, the pieces began to fit together in Cadfael’s mind. He realized that Columbanus might have been driven by obsession, believing he was chosen by the saint. If Rhisiart had confronted him, the argument could have turned deadly.
The villagers were ready to punish Engelard, but Sioned refused to let them. She boldly declared she would not marry anyone until her father’s true killer was found. Her courage touched many hearts, and Cadfael used the time to gather more clues. He discovered that Columbanus had taken a secret vow to bring Saint Winifred to Shrewsbury at any cost. He had mistaken his own pride for divine calling. When Cadfael confronted him gently, Columbanus broke down, his face pale and frightened. He confessed that Rhisiart had blocked his path and that, in a moment of madness, he had shot him.
Cadfael, filled with pity, promised that his confession would remain private if he repented truly. But before he could act further, Columbanus fell ill and collapsed during prayer. Some said he was struck by divine justice; others believed his guilt crushed him. He died soon after, murmuring prayers of forgiveness. The monks, shaken and silent, took this as a sign from heaven that the saint’s will had been done. Prior Robert quickly declared that the miracle had proved their cause and ordered the bones to be exhumed.
Cadfael saw the pain in Sioned’s eyes as her father was buried again. He knew that taking the saint’s remains would only deepen the wound between the Welsh and the English. In a quiet, moonlit night, Cadfael went alone to Saint Winifred’s grave. There, he spoke softly, promising that he meant no harm. He made a bold decision—he removed the saint’s bones but replaced them with Rhisiart’s body instead. He believed the true holiness lay in peace and justice, not in relics and fame. Then, he sealed the grave carefully so that no one would ever know.
The next morning, the monks carried the bones away with solemn ceremony, believing they had Saint Winifred’s relics. The villagers accepted it quietly, thinking perhaps it was God’s will. Only Sioned and Engelard noticed the faint smile on Cadfael’s face. They guessed what he had done but said nothing. For them, justice had been done—not through vengeance, but through mercy. The saint would remain in her land, and Rhisiart would rest among those he loved.
As the monks began their journey back to Shrewsbury, Cadfael rode at the end of the line, thoughtful and calm. He knew Prior Robert would build a shrine around the bones, unaware of the truth. He did not see it as deceit, but as divine irony. The Abbey would gain its relic, the villagers would keep their saint’s spirit, and an innocent man would go free. Sometimes, Cadfael thought, God’s will worked through human hands in quiet, unexpected ways.
Sioned and Engelard were soon married, uniting love and forgiveness in a village that had known sorrow. Father Huw blessed them, and the people began to heal. The memory of Rhisiart lived on with respect, and strange stories spread of how Saint Winifred’s presence could be felt in two places at once. Pilgrims would later visit Shrewsbury, claiming miracles near the new shrine, while others in Gwytherin spoke of blessings and answered prayers by the old grave. Cadfael smiled whenever he heard these tales.
Back in Shrewsbury, the monks rejoiced at their success. Prior Robert took credit, Brother Jerome sang praises, and the Abbey became famous for its holy relic. Only Cadfael kept his silence, tending to his herbs and praying for those who had suffered. He found comfort in knowing that truth had triumphed in a quiet, hidden way. His heart was at peace, for he had protected both the faith of the monks and the dignity of the villagers.
Years later, travelers passing through Shrewsbury would hear the story of the saint who brought miracles wherever she went. None of them knew the full truth, but Cadfael did not need them to. He understood that holiness could live in the heart of a humble man as much as in the bones of a saint. His wisdom grew deeper with time, and he often thought of Rhisiart’s courage, Sioned’s love, and Engelard’s loyalty as examples of true goodness.
When spring came again, the Abbey’s gardens bloomed with color. Cadfael walked among his herbs, feeling the warm sun and the peace that only truth could bring. He thought of the long journey to Wales and the strange twists of fate that had led him there. The world, he mused, was full of mysteries that could never be solved by force—only by kindness and understanding. And in his quiet heart, he prayed for all who had played their part in that sacred tale, trusting that the saint herself would smile upon the secret he carried forever.