Listen Full Story:
Libby Day was only seven years old when her mother and two older sisters were brutally murdered one winter night on their Kansas farm. She was the only survivor, and her testimony sent her fifteen-year-old brother, Ben, to prison for the rest of his life. For nearly three decades she lived off donations and the sympathy of strangers, haunted by that night but never questioning the version of events she’d given as a child—that Ben, a disturbed teenager dabbling in Satanism, had slaughtered their family. Now, at thirty-one, her charity money is gone, and she’s bitter, isolated, and desperate for cash. When a group of amateur investigators calling themselves the Kill Club contact her, she reluctantly agrees to meet them. They are obsessed with famous crimes and believe Ben is innocent. For a fee, they ask Libby to revisit the case, to dig into the past and speak to anyone who might shed new light on what happened. Libby doesn’t believe them, but she needs the money.
She begins by seeking out people connected to that night. Each meeting stirs old memories she has tried to bury. She visits her imprisoned brother for the first time since the trial. Ben is quiet, resigned, and oddly evasive. His demeanor plants a small seed of doubt in her. Could he really have done it? Still, Libby clings to the only truth she’s ever known. Yet, as she starts tracing the fragments of that terrible night, the story she told herself begins to unravel. She finds people who remember rumors of devil worship, animal sacrifices, and whispered accusations that painted Ben as a monster. But she also learns about the poverty and desperation that plagued their family—the single mother, Patty Day, struggling to keep the failing farm; the creditors threatening to take everything; and a community eager to believe in evil when they saw teenage rebellion.
Back in 1985, Patty Day had been sinking under crushing debt. Her land was worthless, her bills piled high, and her anxiety had grown unbearable. She loved her children fiercely but saw no way out. Ben, meanwhile, was an angry, confused boy. He spent his days at school being mocked by rich classmates and his nights drifting with dangerous friends—Trey and Krissi, older kids from town who drew him into petty crime, drugs, and talk of Satanic rituals. Trey, a manipulative thrill-seeker, enjoyed pushing Ben’s boundaries, teasing him with stories of sacrifice and power. Krissi, who had once accused Ben of molesting her, had lied under pressure from adults who wanted to blame someone. In reality, Ben was lost, trying to assert control in a life spinning apart.
As Libby tracks down Krissi, now a grown woman, she finds someone consumed by guilt. Krissi admits her mother forced her to lie about Ben. That revelation rattles Libby. She meets others from Ben’s past—Trey’s old associates, washed-up and bitter, who drop hints of darker things that happened that winter. Each clue leads her deeper into the shadows of her family’s life. She uncovers evidence that the Satanic panic of the 1980s may have twisted the investigation. The police had wanted a simple story: a rebellious teenager turned killer. No one looked too closely at other suspects.
Meanwhile, Libby recalls flashes of that night: the creak of floorboards, her mother’s cries, the blood, the cold. Her mind had blocked much of it out, but the memories are resurfacing. She remembers hiding in the fields until morning, freezing and terrified. The Kill Club helps her piece together a timeline. Ben had left the house that night with Trey and a girl named Diondra. Diondra, a spoiled, manipulative girl from a wealthy family, had been Ben’s secret girlfriend. When Libby finds her years later living under an alias, Diondra still keeps the past buried. She has a teenage daughter who looks exactly like the baby she carried in 1985—the pregnancy no one in the Day family knew about. Libby realizes this girl is Ben’s daughter. The discovery shocks her and begins to clarify the motives behind the tragedy.
Back in the past, Patty Day had reached her breaking point. Overwhelmed by bills, she considered selling the farm to a neighbor named Calvin Diehl, who offered far less than it was worth. When she hesitated, Diehl turned threatening. At the same time, Patty confided in a local hitman, Runner Day—her abusive ex-husband and Ben’s father—without realizing he was scheming for money himself. Desperate to provide for her children, she contemplated the unthinkable: arranging her own death so the insurance would save them. But before she could act, events spiraled out of control.
That night, Ben returned home with Trey and Diondra. Diondra, jealous and high, fought with Patty when her pregnancy came out. In the chaos, Diondra attacked Patty, and Trey joined in. Ben tried to stop them, but he was too scared and confused. When Patty fell, bleeding, he ran to protect his little sisters. Diondra and Trey turned on the younger girls to silence witnesses. Libby, hiding in the shadows, saw only glimpses—enough to think her brother was part of it. She escaped through a window and fled into the snowy fields, her tiny footprints marking the path of survival.
In the present, Libby confronts Diondra after piecing the truth together. Diondra tries to manipulate her again, pretending nothing happened, but Libby notices the signs of guilt everywhere. When she mentions contacting the police, Diondra panics. A violent struggle breaks out, and Diondra flees with her daughter. Libby barely survives the encounter. The police finally intervene, and Ben’s innocence is proven after nearly twenty-five years in prison. He had kept silent to protect Diondra and his unborn child, believing confessing would destroy them both. His silence cost him his life.
Libby visits Ben one last time after his release. There is no joy in their reunion, only a quiet understanding of shared loss. She realizes how fear and poverty twisted their family, how lies built a cage around them. Her mother’s love, her brother’s sacrifice, and her own survival were all pieces of a dark puzzle finally solved. For the first time, she feels something close to peace.
Years of bitterness lift as Libby stands on the edge of the empty farm where it all began. The house is gone, the fields overgrown, but the ghosts remain. She knows she will never escape the memory entirely, but the truth has given her a fragile freedom. The darkness that once defined her life no longer owns her. She leaves the field behind, carrying both the weight of what happened and the strength of having faced it at last.