Listen Full Story:
Read Full Story:
Harriet Vane returned to Shrewsbury College, Oxford, for its annual Gaudy reunion, years after she had graduated. She was now a successful writer of detective stories, though her reputation still carried the shadow of her infamous murder trial, where she had once been accused of poisoning her lover. At the reunion, Harriet was both nostalgic and uneasy. The elegant halls, the sound of old friends’ laughter, and the timeless serenity of Oxford stirred memories of youth and idealism. Yet, behind the beauty of the place, she sensed a quiet tension among the women of the college. Old academic rivalries, unspoken judgments, and the contrast between marriage, career, and scholarship still haunted many of them.
During the celebrations, Harriet received an anonymous note slipped into her belongings. It was crude and threatening—filled with venom and slander, calling her immoral and unworthy. It disturbed her deeply, though she tried to laugh it off. When she returned to London, the message lingered in her mind, as did the strange feeling that something was wrong at Shrewsbury. A few months later, she received a letter from the college’s Dean, asking her to return. There had been a series of malicious incidents—anonymous poison-pen letters, vandalism, and disturbing pranks targeting the women scholars. The college authorities wanted to keep the matter quiet but needed help to find the culprit. Because of Harriet’s skill in solving fictional crimes and her previous connection to Lord Peter Wimsey, they hoped she could discreetly investigate.
When Harriet arrived at the college, she sensed an uneasy atmosphere. The women were anxious but proud; they wanted to protect the college’s reputation, yet the fear of scandal loomed large. Books had been torn, rooms defaced, and obscene graffiti scrawled across the walls. Personal belongings were stolen or destroyed, and cruel letters circulated among staff and students. There was no physical harm, but the emotional toll was immense. It felt like someone within the college was intent on poisoning the very soul of their community.
Harriet quietly began her inquiries. She lived among the scholars, observing their habits and interactions. The academic life seemed peaceful on the surface—students reading in gardens, professors debating in the Senior Common Room—but tension simmered underneath. Some of the dons were married to their work, others bitter about lost opportunities or unfulfilled love. Harriet listened carefully to their conversations, noting jealousies, ambitions, and quiet despair.
Soon, more incidents occurred. A set of gowns was ripped apart in the night. Pages were torn from valuable manuscripts. Poisonous letters accused faculty members of hypocrisy and immorality. One young student, fragile and impressionable, suffered a breakdown and fled from the college in tears. Harriet was both outraged and fascinated. The malice seemed so deliberate, yet so personal—it could only come from someone who knew the college intimately.
Lord Peter Wimsey, the brilliant detective who had once saved Harriet’s life, appeared briefly in her thoughts. Their relationship was complicated—founded on gratitude and mutual admiration, but shadowed by her unwillingness to marry him. She respected his intelligence and kindness, yet feared losing her independence. Still, when the situation grew dangerous, Harriet realized she needed help. She wrote to him, and he soon came to Oxford under the pretense of visiting her casually.
Peter’s arrival brought warmth and balance to Harriet’s increasingly tense world. Together, they studied the pattern of attacks, discussing motives late into the night under the old stone archways. Harriet admired how calmly he reasoned through chaos, how he saw human weakness with compassion rather than judgment. Peter, in turn, admired her courage and intellect—how she faced fear with integrity. Their bond deepened, though she still hesitated to let it turn into love.
The attacks escalated. One evening, Harriet discovered a pile of burned papers in a wastebasket and a destroyed academic thesis. Another time, she found a note threatening suicide. The vandal seemed to be breaking under their own hatred, losing control. The mystery became more psychological than physical—what drove someone to such hatred of women’s learning and independence? Harriet began to suspect that the saboteur was a woman herself, someone who saw intellectual ambition as dangerous, sinful, or futile.
Peter suggested that the motive might lie not in ideology but in personal trauma—someone who had once suffered humiliation within these walls. As Harriet pieced the evidence together, she recalled stories of past students who had failed or been disgraced. One name, in particular, emerged: Annie Wilson, a former scout (college servant) whose husband had committed suicide after being dismissed for theft. The scandal had quietly destroyed her life, and her connection to the college had ended bitterly. Harriet began to suspect that Annie—or someone close to her—was responsible for the revenge campaign.
Late one night, as Harriet was walking through the quad, she saw a shadow move behind the cloisters. She followed, heart pounding, until she came face to face with a figure tearing down notices from the wall. It was the college’s old servant, Miss Annie Wilson. Confronted, Annie broke down hysterically. She confessed that she had been the one sending the letters and destroying property. Her hatred had grown over years of bitterness and grief. She blamed the intellectual women for her husband’s death and saw their independence as blasphemy. The attacks had been her twisted way of punishing them for what she believed they represented—coldness, pride, and the destruction of family life.
Harriet felt an overwhelming mix of pity and horror. Annie was taken away quietly, and the matter was hushed up to preserve the college’s dignity. Yet the experience left Harriet changed. She saw how fragile the balance was between intellect and emotion, reason and passion, freedom and responsibility. In a world that still distrusted educated women, the attacks had been a cruel reflection of society’s deeper prejudices.
After the ordeal, the college began to recover. Peace slowly returned, though some of the women remained shaken. Harriet stayed a little longer, walking through the old gardens, listening to the bells echoing across the quad. She thought about what it meant to live a life of the mind—to choose thought over comfort, and independence over conformity. The events had shown her that intelligence alone could not guard against pain or madness; only compassion could.
Peter returned to Oxford to see her before she left. In the quiet of the college grounds, they spoke frankly at last. Harriet admitted how deeply she respected him, how much his presence had steadied her. He, in turn, told her that he loved her not for her vulnerability but for her strength—that he wanted her as an equal, not as someone to protect. For the first time, Harriet realized she could love him without losing herself. When he proposed again, she accepted—not out of dependence, but of free choice.
Their union symbolized harmony between intellect and emotion, logic and love. Together, they left the college, hand in hand, walking through the serene Oxford night where the bells tolled softly over the river. The shadow that had darkened the women’s college lifted at last, leaving behind not just peace but understanding—the quiet triumph of integrity, forgiveness, and human connection.